Assessment of Costs

Abandoned Appeals and Applications for Leave to Appeal

• CACV3839 CACV3841 CACV3976 Yashcheshen v. Government of Saskatchewan, November 29, 2023, Groothuis
• CACV3893 Piett v Canada Revenue Agency, May 30, 2023, Groothuis
• CACV4025 Milburn v Sansom, May 12, 2023, Groothuis
• CACV3970 Allison et al v Janssen-Ortho Inc. et al, October 14, 2022, Groothuis
• CACV3995 Furneaux v Furneaux, August 3, 2022, Groothuis
• CACV3863 Kish v Facebook Canada Ltd. et al, Jan. 10, 2022, Groothuis
• CACV3378 Grover Holdings Ltd. v City of Saskatoon, July 20, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3489 Dr. Satyam Patel v The Saskatchewan Health Authority and The Practitioner Staff Appeals Tribunal, Dec. 5, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV3353 Mark Leeb and 855473 Alberta Ltd. v Nora Hignell, November 4, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV3053 Lloyd Hanna v Nancy Beckman, April 8, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV2921 Larry Ayers v Scott Summach, Timothy Tkachuk, Kenton Summach, Roger Magneson, Kelly Blanch, Bernie Sabiston, Ronald Miller, Clayton Barry, McDougall Gauley LLP, CPC Networks Corp. and Jack Adams, May 23, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV3000 Colin Chatfield v Bell Mobility Inc., Bell Aliant Regional Communications, Limited Partnership, MTS Inc., Rogers Communications Partnership, Saskatchewan Telecommunications, Saskatchewan Telecommunications Holding Corporation, TELEMOBILE Company, TELUS Communications Inc., TELUS Corporation, TELUS Communications Company, Saskatchewan Telecommunications and Saskatchewan Telecommunications Holding Corporations, May 17, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV2492 Leon Brian Sorenson v Tamara Jayne Swales, November 24, 2014, Baldwin
• CACV2578 Denise Theresa Fehr v Julius Andrew Turta, November 20, 2014, Baldwin
• CACV2324 Rachel Resch v Sean Dufour, December 18, 2012, Baldwin

Applications – Simple or Complex

• CACV3907 Patel v. McMurtry et al, December 8. 2023, Groothuis
• CACV3995 Furneaux v Furneaux, August 3, 2022, Groothuis
• CACV3660 Dean v Koczka, March 28, 2022, Groothuis
• CACV3602 Heffernan v Prince Albert Chief of Police, Nov. 26, 2021, Groothuis
• CACV3524 Tyacke v Tyacke, Sept. 14, 2021, Groothuis
• CACV3664 Steven Mitchell and Steveco Construction Ltd. v Resort Village of Candle Lake, July 13, 2021, Groothuis
• CACV3554 Anderson v The Saskatchewan Apprenticeship and Trade Certification Commission, September 30, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3623 Wilchuk v Westfield Twins Condominium Corporation, September 9, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3562 Myrglod v Kelln, July 9, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3268 Veolia Water Technologies, Inc., successor by merger to HPD, LLC and K+S Potash Canada General Partnership, June 19, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3262 Joseph Melnick v Angela Tapp, October 5, 2018, Baldwin
• CACV3022 Marguerite Kirk and Paul Kirk v Gerald Kirk, Celeste Barnes and Dale Linn, QC in his capacity as Interim Administrator of the Estate of Anastasia Kirk, December 12, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV2886 Akomeno Oruaroghene Egware v Oluwatomi Opeyemi Egware, January 24, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV2237 Blaine Kenneth Collins, Mark Joseph Collins and Bradley Kenneth Edward Collins v Resort Village of Saskatchewan Beach, Sharie Hall, Malcolm Graham, Lorna Friess, Dennis Day, Trevor Gates, Brian MacDonald, Randy John Grandish, Wenda Francis-Niels and Bentley Hilderman, September 12, 2016, Baldwin
• CACV2225 John Den Hollander v Tiger Courier Inc., October 8, 2015, Baldwin
• CACV2492 Leon Brian Sorenson v Tamara Jayne Swales, November 24, 2014, Baldwin
• CACV2578 Denise Theresa Fehr v Julius Andrew Turta, November 20, 2014, Baldwin
• CACV2300 Paulsen & Son Excavating Ltd. v Royal Bank of Canada, August 15, 2013, Baldwin
• CACV1987 & CACV2061 Mackenzie Malcolm Stelter v Kathleen Carol Stelter, March 1, 2013, Baldwin
• CACV2251 Michael Hogan v Jennifer Hogan, February 25, 2013, Baldwin
• CACV2324 Rachel Resch v Sean Dufour, December 18, 2012, Baldwin

Column of Tariff

• CACV3864 Hoedel v Westjet et al, February 21, 2024, Groothuis
• CACV4025 Milburn v Sansom, May 12, 2023, Groothuis
• CACV3837 Granquist v Lemond, March 8, 2023, Groothuis
• CACV3664 Steven Mitchell and Steveco Construction Ltd. v Resort Village of Candle Lake, July 13, 2021, Groothuis
• CACV3622 Jones v Jones, March 25, 2021, Groothuis
• CACV3340 Lonsdale v Evans, May 28, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3001 Marlene Gail Primeau and Allan Joseph Primeau v Arnold Arthur Kuhn and Judith Kuhn, January 8, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV2931 McKay Career Training Inc. v Bob Baker and 613791 Saskatchewan Ltd. and City of Saskatoon, October 18, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV3192 Shinkaruk Enterprises Ltd. and Peter Shinkaruk v City of Saskatoon, June 13, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV3053 Lloyd Hanna v Nancy Beckman, April 8, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV2860 Attorney General of Canada on behalf of Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada v Merchant Law Group LLP, March 27, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV3022 Marguerite Kirk and Paul Kirk v Gerald Kirk, Celeste Barnes and Dale Linn, QC in his capacity as Interim Administrator of the Estate of Anastasia Kirk, December 12, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV2501 Dwight Kosolofski v Danielle Kosolofski, September 27, 2016, Baldwin
• CA1396 & CACV2644 Jorgenson v ASL Paving Ltd., November 30, 2015, Baldwin
• CACV1987 & CACV2061 Mackenzie Malcolm Stelter v Kathleen Carol Stelter, March 1, 2013, Baldwin
• CACV2251 Michael Hogan v Jennifer Hogan, February 25, 2013, Baldwin
• CACV2207 Eagle Eye Investments Inc. v CPC Networks Corp., January 8, 2013, Baldwin
• CA1516 Sonia Vicki Smith v Mervin Bryan Smith, February 9, 2009, Schwann

Cross Appeal

• CACV3409 Ituna Investment LP v Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial Services, Inc., Dec. 13, 2021, Groothuis

Disbursements (Proper Vouchers, Online Research, Photocopying, Travel Costs)

• CACV3409 Ituna Investment LP v Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial Services, Inc., Dec. 13, 2021, Groothuis
• CACV3382 Dungey v Dungey, April 6, 2021, Groothuis
• CACV3554 Anderson v The Saskatchewan Apprenticeship and Trade Certification Commission, September 30, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3268 Veolia Water Technologies, Inc., successor by merger to HPD, LLC and K+S Potash Canada General Partnership, June 19, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3247 Hanson v Hanson, March 18, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3229 605499 Saskatchewan Ltd., 605857 Saskatchewan Ltd., Harold Neufeld, Pierre Neufeld, Alexander M. Neufeld, Nicholas H. Neufeld and Suzanne F. Fischer v Rifle Shot Oil Corp. and Surface Rights Arbitration Board, February 19, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3001 Marlene Gail Primeau and Allan Joseph Primeau v Arnold Arthur Kuhn and Judith Kuhn, January 8, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV2931 McKay Career Training Inc. v Bob Baker and 613791 Saskatchewan Ltd. and City of Saskatoon, October 18, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV3028 Robert L. Stevenson v Ronald Lewis O’Byrne, April 26, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV3151 Douglas Cameron v The Saskatchewan Institute of Agrologists, April 2, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV2860 Attorney General of Canada on behalf of Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada v Merchant Law Group LLP, March 27, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV2965 Agri Resource Mgt. 2001 Ltd. v Saskatchewan Crop Insurance Corporation, August 30, 2018, Baldwin
• CACV3022 Marguerite Kirk and Paul Kirk v Gerald Kirk, Celeste Barnes and Dale Linn, QC in his capacity as Interim Administrator of the Estate of Anastasia Kirk, December 12, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV2886 Akomeno Oruaroghene Egware v Oluwatomi Opeyemi Egware, January 24, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV2225 John Den Hollander v Tiger Courier Inc., October 8, 2015, Baldwin
• CACV2690 Leonard Borowski v Douglas Ukrainetz carrying on business under the name and style of Ukrainetz Auctioneering, June 29, 2015, Baldwin
• CACV2190 Robert Helland v Flexxifinger QD Industries Inc., October 20, 2014, Baldwin
• CACV1987 & CACV2061 Mackenzie Malcolm Stelter v Kathleen Carol Stelter, March 1, 2013, Baldwin
• CACV2080 V. Jensen & Sons Co-operative Stockfarm Limited and Barry Jensen v Agricultural Credit Corporation of Saskatchewan, March 15, 2012, Baldwin
• CA1245 Paddy Ann O’Reilly v Daryl Allan Taylor, February 2, 2009, Schwann
• CA1461 Kirk Harold Knudson v Raelyn Diane Knudson, November 12, 2008, Schwann

Fee Waiver

• CACV3242 Reginald Wilchuck v Westfield Twins Condominium Corporation, March 26, 2019, Baldwin

GST/PST

• CACV3151 Douglas Cameron v The Saskatchewan Institute of Agrologists, April 2, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV2318 Melanie Kemery v Chad Kemery, February 8, 2013, Baldwin

Proration of or Partial Entitlement to Tariff Items

• CACV3918 Stack v Stack, May 12, 2022, Groothuis
• CACV3192 Shinkaruk Enterprises Ltd. and Peter Shinkaruk v City of Saskatoon, June 13, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV3053 Lloyd Hanna v Nancy Beckman, April 8, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV3262 Joseph Melnick v Angela Tapp, October 5, 2018, Baldwin
• CACV2965 Agri Resource Mgt. 2001 Ltd. v Saskatchewan Crop Insurance Corporation, August 30, 2018, Baldwin
• CACV2827 Linton Carlyle Potzus v Kendra Rae Potzus, August 15, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV2921 Larry Ayers v Scott Summach, Timothy Tkachuk, Kenton Summach, Roger Magneson, Kelly Blanch, Bernie Sabiston, Ronald Miller, Clayton Barry, McDougall Gauley LLP, CPC Networks Corp. and Jack Adams, May 23, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV3000 Colin Chatfield v Bell Mobility Inc., Bell Aliant Regional Communications, Limited Partnership, MTS Inc., Rogers Communications Partnership, Saskatchewan Telecommunications, Saskatchewan Telecommunications Holding Corporation, TELEMOBILE Company, TELUS Communications Inc., TELUS Corporation, TELUS Communications Company, Saskatchewan Telecommunications and Saskatchewan Telecommunications Holding Corporations, May 17, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV2324 Rachel Resch v Sean Dufour, December 18, 2012, Baldwin
• CA1964 Michael Seon v Ministry of Saskatchewan Health, Regina Qu’Appelle Health Region, Regina Pioneer Village, Alger Seon and Public Guardian and Trustee, October 12, 2011, Baldwin

Set-Off of Costs

• CACV3525 Eugenio v Eugenio, July 28, 2021, Groothuis

Solicitor/Client Costs

• CACV3382 Dungey v Dungey, April 6, 2021, Groothuis
• CACV3268 Veolia Water Technologies, Inc., successor by merger to HPD, LLC and K+S Potash Canada General Partnership, June 19, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV2641 David Robert Allan Viczko and Jennifer Viczko v Yvonne Choquette and Donna Boots, in her capacity as Executrix of the Estate of Joseph Frank Viczko and Farm Credit Canada, November 27, 2017, Baldwin
• CA1223 Lisa Ritchie v Royal Trust Corporation of Canada, August 1, 2008, Schwann

Taxation Hearing Costs

• CACV2931 McKay Career Training Inc. v Bob Baker and 613791 Saskatchewan Ltd. and City of Saskatoon, October 18, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV2860 Attorney General of Canada on behalf of Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada v Merchant Law Group LLP, March 27, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV2641 David Robert Allan Viczko and Jennifer Viczko v Yvonne Choquette and Donna Boots, in her capacity as Executrix of the Estate of Joseph Frank Viczko and Farm Credit Canada, November 27, 2017, Baldwin

2024

• CACV3864 Hoedel v Westjet et al., February 21, 2024, Groothuis

2023

• CACV3383 Anderson v Anderson, June 29, 2023, Groothuis
• CACV3635/CACV3636 & CACV3638 Pedigree Poultry et al, June 22, 2023, Groothuis
• CACV3893 Piett v Canada Revenue Agency, May 30, 2023, Groothuis
• CACV4025 Milburn v Sansom, May 12, 2023, Groothuis
• CACV3837 Granquist v Lemond, March 8, 2023, Groothuis
• CACV3839/ CACV3841 & CACV3976 Yascheshen v Government of Saskatchewan et al, November 11, 2023, Groothuis
• CACV3907 Patel v McMurtry et al, December 8, 2023, Groothuis

2022

• CACV3970 Allison et al v Janssen-Ortho Inc. et al, October 14, 2022, Groothuis
• CACV3995 Furneaux v Furneaux, August 3, 2022, Groothuis
• CACV3918 Stack v Stack, May 12, 2022, Groothuis
• CACV3660 Dean v Koczka, March 28, 2022, Groothuis
• CACV3863 Kish v Facebook Canada Ltd. et al, Jan. 10, 2022, Groothuis

2021

• CACV3409 Ituna Investment LP v Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial Services, Inc., Dec. 13, 2021, Groothuis
• CACV3602 Heffernan v Prince Albert Chief of Police, Nov. 26, 2021, Groothuis
• CACV3524 Tyacke v Tyacke, Sept. 14, 2021, Groothuis
• CACV3525 Eugenio v Eugenio, July 28, 2021, Groothuis
• CACV3664 Steven Mitchell and Steveco Construction Ltd. v Resort Village of Candle Lake, July 13, 2021, Groothuis
• CACV3382 Dungey v Dungey, April 6, 2021, Groothuis
• CACV3622 Jones v Jones, March 25, 2021, Groothuis

2020

• CACV3554 Anderson v The Saskatchewan Apprenticeship and Trade Certification Commission, September 30, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3623 Wilchuk v Westfield Twins Condominium Corporation, September 9, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3378 Grover Holdings Ltd. v City of Saskatoon, July 20, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3562 Myrglod v Kelln, July 9, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3268 Veolia Water Technologies, Inc., successor by merger to HPD, LLC and K+S Potash Canada General Partnership, June 19, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3340 Lonsdale v Evans, May 28, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3247 Hanson v Hanson, March 18, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3229 605499 Saskatchewan Ltd., 605857 Saskatchewan Ltd., Harold Neufeld, Pierre Neufeld, Alexander M. Neufeld, Nicholas H. Neufeld and Suzanne F. Fischer v Rifle Shot Oil Corp. and Surface Rights Arbitration Board, February 19, 2020, Baldwin
• CACV3001 Marlene Gail Primeau and Allan Joseph Primeau v Arnold Arthur Kuhn and Judith Kuhn, January 8, 2020, Baldwin

2019

• CACV3489 Dr. Satyam Patel v The Saskatchewan Health Authority and The Practitioner Staff Appeals Tribunal, Dec. 5, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV3353 Mark Leeb and 855473 Alberta Ltd. v Nora Hignell, November 4, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV2931 McKay Career Training Inc. v Bob Baker and 613791 Saskatchewan Ltd. and City of Saskatoon, October 18, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV3192 Shinkaruk Enterprises Ltd. and Peter Shinkaruk v City of Saskatoon, June 13, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV3028 Robert L. Stevenson v Ronald Lewis O’Byrne, April 26, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV3053 Lloyd Hanna v Nancy Beckman, April 8, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV3151 Douglas Cameron v The Saskatchewan Institute of Agrologists, April 2, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV2860 Attorney General of Canada on behalf of Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada v Merchant Law Group LLP, March 27, 2019, Baldwin
• CACV3242 Reginald Wilchuck v Westfield Twins Condominium Corporation, March 26, 2019, Baldwin

2018

• CACV3262 Joseph Melnick v Angela Tapp, October 5, 2018, Baldwin
• CACV2965 Agri Resource Mgt. 2001 Ltd. v Saskatchewan Crop Insurance Corporation, August 30, 2018, Baldwin
• CACV3065 Kocsis Transport Ltd. and Ron Kocsis v Aspen Developments Inc. and Attorney General of Canada and Peach Hills Trust Company, January 23, 2018, Baldwin

2017

• CACV3022 Marguerite Kirk and Paul Kirk v Gerald Kirk, Celeste Barnes and Dale Linn, QC in his capacity as Interim Administrator of the Estate of Anastasia Kirk, December 12, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV2641 David Robert Allan Viczko and Jennifer Viczko v Yvonne Choquette and Donna Boots, in her capacity as Executrix of the Estate of Joseph Frank Viczko and Farm Credit Canada, November 27, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV2588 Deborah Hurrell in her capacity as Executrix of the Estate of Marjorie Dean Thorsteinson v William Olson, September 25, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV2827 Linton Carlyle Potzus v Kendra Rae Potzus, August 15, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV2832 Copper Sands Land Corporation v Ed Edwards, June 6, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV2921 Larry Ayers v Scott Summach, Timothy Tkachuk, Kenton Summach, Roger Magneson, Kelly Blanch, Bernie Sabiston, Ronald Miller, Clayton Barry, McDougall Gauley LLP, CPC Networks Corp. and Jack Adams, May 23, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV3000 Colin Chatfield v Bell Mobility Inc., Bell Aliant Regional Communications, Limited Partnership, MTS Inc., Rogers Communications Partnership, Saskatchewan Telecommunications, Saskatchewan Telecommunications Holding Corporation, TELEMOBILE Company, TELUS Communications Inc., TELUS Corporation, TELUS Communications Company, Saskatchewan Telecommunications and Saskatchewan Telecommunications Holding Corporations, May 17, 2017, Baldwin
• CACV2886 Akomeno Oruaroghene Egware v Oluwatomi Opeyemi Egware, January 24, 2017, Baldwin

2016

• CACV2501 Dwight Kosolofski v Danielle Kosolofski, September 27, 2016, Baldwin
• CACV2237 Blaine Kenneth Collins, Mark Joseph Collins and Bradley Kenneth Edward Collins v Resort Village of Saskatchewan Beach, Sharie Hall, Malcolm Graham, Lorna Friess, Dennis Day, Trevor Gates, Brian MacDonald, Randy John Grandish, Wenda Francis-Niels and Bentley Hilderman, September 12, 2016, Baldwin

2015

• CA1396 & CACV2644 Jorgenson v ASL Paving Ltd., November 30, 2015, Baldwin
• CACV2225 John Den Hollander v Tiger Courier Inc., October 8, 2015, Baldwin
• CACV2690 Leonard Borowski v Douglas Ukrainetz carrying on business under the name and style of Ukrainetz Auctioneering, June 29, 2015, Baldwin

2014

• CACV2492 Leon Brian Sorenson v Tamara Jayne Swales, November 24, 2014, Baldwin
• CACV2578 Denise Theresa Fehr v Julius Andrew Turta, November 20, 2014, Baldwin
• CACV2190 Robert Helland v Flexxifinger QD Industries Inc., October 20, 2014, Baldwin
• CACV2110 Thomas Neil Love v Lori Marie Love, January 7, 2014, Baldwin

2013

• CACV2420 MFI Ag Services Ltd. v Lyndon Joseph Sotkowy and Warren James Sotkowy and Nicholas P. Robinson and Merchant Law Group LLP, August 1, 2013, Baldwin
• CACV2300 Paulsen & Son Excavating Ltd. v Royal Bank of Canada, August 15, 2013, Baldwin
• CACV1987 & CACV2061 Mackenzie Malcolm Stelter v Kathleen Carol Stelter, March 1, 2013, Baldwin
• CACV2251 Michael Hogan v Jennifer Hogan, February 25, 2013, Baldwin
• CACV2318 Melanie Kemery v Chad Kemery, February 8, 2013, Baldwin
• CACV2207 Eagle Eye Investments Inc. v CPC Networks Corp., January 8, 2013, Baldwin

2012

• CACV2324 Rachel Resch v Sean Dufour, December 18, 2012, Baldwin
• CACV1993 Larry Markwart v City of Prince Albert, Peter Halayka, City of Prince Albert Board of Police Commissioners, Dale McFee, Prince Albert Parkland Health Region Authority and Nancy Gaveronski, March 30, 2012, Baldwin
• CACV2080 V. Jensen & Sons Co-operative Stockfarm Limited and Barry Jensen v Agricultural Credit Corporation of Saskatchewan, March 15, 2012, Baldwin

2011

• CA1806 Anne Otto v Lillian Ryhorski, Executrix of the Estate of Alice Kapacila, December 15, 2011, Baldwin
• CA1964 Michael Seon v Ministry of Saskatchewan Health, Regina Qu’Appelle Health Region, Regina Pioneer Village, Alger Seon and Public Guardian and Trustee, October 12, 2011, Baldwin

2009

• CA1516 Sonia Vicki Smith v Mervin Bryan Smith, February 9, 2009, Schwann
• CA1245 Paddy Ann O’Reilly v Daryl Allan Taylor, February 2, 2009, Schwann

2008

• CA1461 Kirk Harold Knudson v Raelyn Diane Knudson, November 12, 2008, Schwann
• CA1223 Lisa Ritchie v Royal Trust Corporation of Canada, August 1, 2008, Schwann